All NotesCorporate LawIntellectual Property Rights (IPR)

IPR

Topic 157 Banking FinTech IP

Topic 157 — Banking and FinTech IP Deep-Dive

BANKING + FINTECH IP encompasses software platforms (UPI, mobile banking, payment gateways), AI/ML systems (credit scoring, fraud detection), cybersecurity frameworks, customer interfaces (UX/UI), business processes, brand protection, regulatory technology (RegTech), and emerging crypto/blockchain frameworks. India's fintech sector is the world's 3rd largest, with a $50+ billion industry and major players including Paytm (One97 Communications), PhonePe (Walmart), Razorpay, BharatPe, Pine Labs, Lendingkart, MobiKwik. UPI (Unified Payments Interface) processes 14+ billion transactions monthly in India. The framework integrates: PATENTS (Section 3(k) software exclusion + Section 3(d) business method considerations + CRI Guidelines 2025); COPYRIGHT (Section 2(o) software literary work); TRADE MARKS (financial brand protection); TRADE SECRETS (algorithms + customer data + financial models); DESIGNS (UI/UX + interface configurations); PERSONAL DATA (DPDP Act 2023 + RBI Privacy Framework); CRYPTOCURRENCY (Income Tax Act 2025 + RBI guidelines); SECURITIES (SEBI regulations). Banking IP intersects with: BANKING REGULATION ACT 1949; RBI ACT 1934; PAYMENT AND SETTLEMENT SYSTEMS ACT 2007 (PSS Act); INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY ACT 2000; INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (REASONABLE SECURITY PRACTICES AND PROCEDURES) RULES 2011; DPDP ACT 2023; FOREIGN EXCHANGE MANAGEMENT ACT 1999 (FEMA); PMLA (Prevention of Money Laundering Act 2002). Recent landmark cases shape fintech IP: ENGINEERING ANALYSIS v. CIT (AIR 2021 SC 1394) software royalty taxation; CRYPTOCURRENCY ASSESSMENT FRAMEWORK 2022 (30% tax under Section 115BBH); RBI v. INTERNET AND MOBILE ASSOCIATION OF INDIA (2020 SCC OnLine SC 282) crypto trading; ANI v. OPENAI 2024 AI training (relevant for fintech AI). RBI'S DIGITAL BANKING UNITS (DBUs) framework, ACCOUNT AGGREGATOR FRAMEWORK, and DIGITAL LENDING GUIDELINES 2022 provide regulatory framework. India's INDIA STACK (Aadhaar + UPI + DigiLocker) provides foundational digital infrastructure. This topic walks through every aspect of banking + fintech IP — software protection, payment systems, regulatory framework, and recent reforms.

1. Indian Banking + Fintech Industry Framework

A. Industry Scale + Strategic Importance

✅ India's Fintech Industry

GLOBAL POSITIONING: · 3rd largest fintech market globally. · $50B+ industry. · Highest fintech adoption rate (87%). · UPI: 14B+ transactions monthly. · Major innovation hub. MAJOR PLAYERS: · Paytm (One97 Communications). · PhonePe (Walmart-owned). · Razorpay. · BharatPe. · Pine Labs. · Lendingkart. · MobiKwik. · Cred. · INDmoney. · Groww. · Zerodha. KEY SEGMENTS: · Payment platforms (UPI, mobile wallets). · Lending platforms (P2P, BNPL). · Insurance (InsurTech). · Investment (WealthTech). · Cryptocurrency (subject to evolving regulation). · Digital banking. · RegTech (regulatory technology). · Banking-as-a-Service (BaaS). · Account aggregators. STRATEGIC IMPORTANCE: · Financial inclusion driver. · Digital infrastructure. · Foreign exchange. · Innovation hub. · Consumer empowerment.

2. Software + AI Patentability for FinTech

A. Section 3(k) Framework Application

✅ FinTech Patentability Workshop

CHALLENGE: · Most fintech innovations involve software. · Section 3(k) excludes "computer programme per se". · Many fintech inventions appear as "business methods". · OpenTV 2023 — business methods absolute bar. NAVIGATION STRATEGY (CRI Guidelines 2025): 1. EMPHASISE TECHNICAL EFFECT · Performance improvements. · Security enhancements. · Resource optimization. · Network efficiency. 2. AVOID PURE BUSINESS METHOD FRAMING · Don't claim "method of business processing". · Frame as TECHNICAL solution. · Highlight HARDWARE integration. 3. SYSTEM-LEVEL CLAIMS · Network architecture. · Memory management. · Processor utilisation. · Database integration. 4. SECURITY-FOCUSED INVENTIONS · Encryption methods. · Authentication frameworks. · Fraud detection algorithms. · Privacy-preserving computations. 5. SPECIFIC TECHNICAL IMPROVEMENTS · Real-time processing. · Distributed systems. · Concurrent transaction handling. · Settlement optimization. KEY CASES TO LEVERAGE: · Ferid Allani 2019 — technical effect. · Microsoft 2023 — software with technical effect. · Ab Initio 2024 — blockchain technical effect. · Raytheon 2023 — cognitive technical effect. WHAT TO AVOID: · Pure business method (OpenTV 2023). · Generic AI/ML (Blackberry 2024). · Abstract logic (multiple cases). · Pure financial calculations (multiple cases).

3. Copyright + Software for FinTech

A. Software Copyright Strategy

  • Section 2(o) Copyright Act — software as literary work.
  • Form XIV — software registration.
  • ₹500 fee + source code samples.
  • Section 14(b) — adaptation rights.
  • Engineering Analysis 2021 — taxation framework.

B. Source Code Protection Strategy

✅ Source Code Protection Strategy

INTEGRATED PROTECTION: 1. COPYRIGHT REGISTRATION (Form XIV) · Registration optional but advantageous. · Source code samples (first + last 10 pages). · Block out trade secrets. 2. TRADE SECRET PROTECTION · Comprehensive NDAs. · Employee assignments. · Source code repositories security. · Access logs. 3. CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENTS · Mutual + perpetual. · Specific identification (Rochem rule). · Cross-border protection. 4. EMPLOYMENT FRAMEWORK · Section 17(c) work for hire. · Explicit assignment for contractors. · Confidentiality during + post. · Non-compete during employment only. 5. CRYPTOGRAPHIC PROTECTION · Encryption of source code. · Hash verification. · Digital signatures. · TPM/RMI under Section 65A/65B. 6. CYBER SECURITY · IT Act 2000 framework. · Information Technology (Reasonable Security Practices) Rules 2011. · Section 43A liability framework. INTEGRATION POINTS: · DPDP Act 2023 personal data. · RBI cybersecurity framework. · FEMA cross-border data. · Banking Regulation Act compliance.

4. UPI + Payment Systems IP Framework

A. UPI Foundational Framework

  • Unified Payments Interface (UPI) — launched 2016.
  • National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) — operator.
  • Open architecture allowing third-party applications.
  • 14B+ transactions monthly in India.
  • UPI 2.0 — additional features (overdraft, mandates).
  • UPI Lite — small-value transactions.
  • UPI International — cross-border framework.

B. Payment + Settlement Systems Act 2007

  • PSS Act 2007 — primary statute.
  • RBI as regulator.
  • Authorisation framework.
  • Operational guidelines.
  • Penalties + enforcement.

C. Major Payment Innovations

  • UPI (NPCI).
  • IMPS (Immediate Payment Service).
  • Aadhaar Pay.
  • NETC (National Electronic Toll Collection — FASTag).
  • NACH (National Automated Clearing House).
  • RuPay (national payment card).
  • eRUPI (digital voucher).
  • CBDC (Central Bank Digital Currency — pilots).

5. Cryptocurrency + Blockchain

A. Indian Cryptocurrency Framework

✅ Cryptocurrency Framework

STATUS: · No specific cryptocurrency law. · RBI framework evolving. · Income Tax Act 2025 effective 1 April 2026. INCOME TAX FRAMEWORK: · Section 115BBH (introduced 2022) — 30% flat tax on virtual digital assets (VDA). · No deductions allowed. · No loss set-off. · 1% TDS under Section 194S. · Mandatory ITR-2/ITR-3 reporting. RBI v. INTERNET AND MOBILE ASSOCIATION (2020 SCC OnLine SC 282): · Supreme Court: Lifted RBI banking ban on crypto trading. · Trading + holding permitted. · Banking services available. CONTINUING CONCERNS: · Money laundering (PMLA). · Investor protection. · Foreign exchange (FEMA). · DPDP integration. · Cross-border transactions. CBDC (DIGITAL RUPEE): · RBI pilot project. · Central Bank Digital Currency. · Wholesale + retail variants. · Programmable rupee features. WEB3 + DEFI: · Decentralised finance emerging. · NFTs (Section 115BBH applies). · Cross-border framework. · DPDP integration.

B. Blockchain IP Framework

  • Software with technical effect (CRI Guidelines 2025).
  • Ab Initio 2024:DHC:5708 — blockchain technical effect.
  • Specific blockchain inventions patentable.
  • Smart contracts framework emerging.
  • NFT framework — Hermès v. Rothschild (US 2023).
  • Cross-border blockchain governance.

6. Banking IP Brand + Trademark Protection

A. Banking Trademark Strategy

✅ Banking Trademark Workshop

BANKING TRADEMARK CONSIDERATIONS: 1. CORPORATE BRAND · Multi-class registration. · Class 36 (insurance + financial). · Class 9 (financial software). · Class 35 (advertising + business). 2. PRODUCT TRADEMARKS · Account names. · Card products. · Investment products. · Service offerings. 3. DIGITAL PROPERTIES · Domain names. · App brand names. · Mobile platform branding. · Social media handles. 4. WELL-KNOWN STATUS · Established Indian banks (Section 11(6) + Rule 124). · Cross-class protection. · Article 6bis Paris Convention. INDIAN BANKING WELL-KNOWN MARKS: · State Bank of India (SBI). · HDFC Bank. · ICICI Bank. · Axis Bank. · Kotak Mahindra Bank. · Punjab National Bank. · Bank of Baroda. · Canara Bank. · India Post Payments Bank. · Paytm. · PhonePe. · Razorpay.

7. Data Protection + DPDP Integration

A. DPDP Act 2023 + Banking Integration

✅ Banking + DPDP Integration

EFFECTIVE FEBRUARY 2025: SCOPE FOR BANKING: · Customer data (KYC, transactions). · Account information. · Behavioural data. · Cross-border data flows. · Cloud services data. KEY PROVISIONS: · Notification framework. · Consent requirements. · Data minimisation. · Data Principal rights. · Cross-border restrictions. · Data Fiduciary obligations. INTEGRATION WITH BANKING: · RBI cybersecurity framework. · Banking Regulation Act 1949. · Information Technology Act 2000. · FEMA cross-border data. · PMLA monitoring. FINANCIAL INSTITUTION OBLIGATIONS: · Specific consent. · Notification of breaches. · Periodic data audits. · Cross-border safeguards. · Privacy by design. DATA LOCALIZATION: · RBI: Sensitive financial data within India. · DPDP framework integration. · Cross-border data transfer permits.

8. Recent FinTech IP Cases

📖 Engineering Analysis Centre v. CIT, AIR 2021 SC 1394

Background — Software royalty taxation under DTAAs.

Holding — Software NOT royalty under DTAAs.

Significance — Critical for fintech tax planning.

📖 RBI v. Internet and Mobile Association of India, 2020 SCC OnLine SC 282

Background — RBI April 2018 circular banning banks from crypto trading services.

Holding — Supreme Court: Banking restriction LIFTED; cryptocurrency trading permitted.

Significance — Foundation for cryptocurrency commercial activity in India.

📖 Ab Initio v. Asst. Controller, 2024:DHC:5708

Background — Blockchain patent application.

Holding — Delhi HC: Blockchain technical effect can establish patentability.

Significance — Modern blockchain patentability framework.

9. Strategic Considerations

✅ For fintech companies — eight points

For software patents, leverage CRI Guidelines 2025 + technical effect.

For source code, integrate copyright + trade secret framework.

For UPI integration, navigate NPCI framework carefully.

For data protection, integrate DPDP Act 2023 (effective February 2025).

For cryptocurrency, leverage Section 115BBH + RBI evolving framework.

For brand protection, register multi-class portfolio (especially Classes 9, 35, 36).

For tax planning, leverage Engineering Analysis 2021 framework.

For cross-border, navigate FEMA + DPDP + RBI frameworks.

10. Memory Aid — Quick Recall

✅ Quick Recall — Banking + FinTech IP

India fintech: 3rd largest globally; $50B+; UPI 14B monthly transactions.

Section 3(k) — software/algorithms not patentable "as such".

CRI Guidelines 2025 — three-step test for fintech.

Frame inventions as TECHNICAL solutions to TECHNICAL problems.

OpenTV 2023 — business methods absolute bar.

Ab Initio 2024:DHC:5708 — blockchain technical effect.

Engineering Analysis 2021 — software royalty taxation.

Software NOT royalty under DTAAs.

PSS Act 2007 + RBI Act 1934 — payment systems framework.

UPI by NPCI — open architecture.

India Stack: Aadhaar + UPI + DigiLocker.

Section 115BBH — 30% tax on cryptocurrency (introduced 2022).

Section 194S — 1% TDS on cryptocurrency.

RBI v. IMAI 2020 SCC OnLine SC 282 — banking ban lifted on crypto trading.

DPDP Act 2023 effective February 2025.

CBDC — Digital Rupee (RBI pilot).

🎯 EXAM POINTERS — TOPIC 157

  • Indian fintech industry: 3rd largest globally; $50B+ industry; 87% adoption rate.
  • UPI processes 14B+ transactions monthly.
  • Section 3(k) Patents Act — software/algorithms not patentable "as such".
  • CRI Guidelines 2025 (29 July 2025) — three-step test for fintech inventions.
  • OpenTV v. Controller (2023:DHC:3305) — business methods absolute bar.
  • Ab Initio v. Asst. Controller (2024:DHC:5708) — blockchain technical effect.
  • Microsoft v. Asst. Controller (2023:DHC:3342) — software with technical effect.
  • Ferid Allani v. UoI (2019:DHC:6944) — technical effect test.
  • Engineering Analysis Centre v. CIT (AIR 2021 SC 1394) — software royalty taxation; software NOT royalty under DTAAs.
  • Section 2(o) Copyright Act — software as literary work.
  • Form XIV — software copyright registration; ₹500.
  • Section 17(c) Copyright Act — work for hire.
  • Section 27 ICA — restraint of trade VOID; goodwill exception.
  • Niranjan Shankar 1967 — during employment OK; Krishna Murgai 1981 — post-employment INVALID.
  • Payment and Settlement Systems Act 2007 (PSS Act) — primary payment systems statute.
  • RBI Act 1934 + Banking Regulation Act 1949 — banking framework.
  • Information Technology Act 2000 + IT Rules 2011 — cybersecurity.
  • Section 43A IT Act — body corporate liability framework.
  • DPDP Act 2023 — effective February 2025; data protection framework.
  • NPCI — operator of UPI + IMPS + RuPay + NACH + NETC + CBDC.
  • India Stack: Aadhaar + UPI + DigiLocker.
  • Section 115BBH (introduced 2022) — 30% flat tax on Virtual Digital Assets (VDA); no deductions or set-off.
  • Section 194S (introduced 2022) — 1% TDS on cryptocurrency.
  • RBI v. Internet and Mobile Association of India (2020 SCC OnLine SC 282) — banking ban LIFTED on crypto trading.
  • CBDC (Digital Rupee) — RBI pilot project; wholesale + retail.
  • FEMA 1999 — cross-border data + transactions framework.
  • Income Tax Act 2025 — effective 1 April 2026.
  • Hermès v. Rothschild (US 2023) — NFT trademark framework.