All NotesCorporate LawCompetition Act, 2002

Competition Act, 2002

Competition Law and Consumer Protection Law Compared

Both bodies of law protect buyers, and they do it from opposite ends of the market. Consumer protection law works on the individual transaction: a buyer who received a defective good, a deficient service or an unfair trade practice complains and obtains compensation. Competition law works on the structure of the market: the Commission examines whether conduct has harmed the competitive process, and what it produces is a penalty and a direction, not compensation. Unfair trade practices, which the MRTP Act had covered, were deliberately left out of the Competition Act, 2002 and now belong to the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

1. The Comparison

Basis

Competition Act, 2002

Consumer Protection Act, 2019

Object

To protect the process of competition in markets

To protect the individual consumer in a transaction

Who may complain

Any person, consumer or association may supply information; no locus is required, following Samir Agrawal v. CCI, (2021) 3 SCC 136

A consumer as defined, or one acting on his behalf, and the regulator in specified cases

What is examined

The effect of conduct on competition within a defined relevant market

The goods supplied, the service rendered and the terms imposed on that buyer

Market power

Central to Section 4 and to the assessment under Section 3(4)

Irrelevant; a small trader is as liable as a large one

Remedy

Penalty, cease and desist, modification of agreements, division of an enterprise

Compensation, replacement, refund, removal of the defect, and penalties for misleading advertisement

Compensation

Only under Section 53N, and only after a finding has attained finality

The principal remedy

Forum

The Commission, with appeal to the Appellate Tribunal

The District, State and National Commissions

Unfair trade practices

Not covered; deliberately omitted in 2002

Covered, and defined in detail

2. The Same Facts under Both

A single course of conduct may attract both statutes, and the two proceedings are independent, Section 62 of the Competition Act providing that it is in addition to and not in derogation of other laws. A misleading claim about a product is an unfair trade practice; if it is made by a dominant enterprise as a means of foreclosing a rival it may also be an abuse. An unfair contractual term imposed on consumers is examined as an unfair contract under the consumer legislation; if imposed by a dominant enterprise it is examined under Section 4(2)(a)(i). What differs is the question asked and the relief obtained, so a complainant who wants money goes to the consumer forum and a complainant who wants the practice stopped across the market supplies information to the Commission.

⚠ Why consumer disputes cannot be sent to arbitration

The point belongs here because it shows how the two statutes treat a consumer's position differently. In Emaar MGF Land Ltd. v. Aftab Singh, (2019) 12 SCC 751 the Supreme Court held that a complaint under the consumer legislation is not liable to be referred to arbitration under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, because the remedy before the consumer fora is a special remedy conferred by a beneficial statute in addition to other remedies. The bar operates at the instance of the consumer, who may choose to arbitrate but cannot be compelled. The Competition Act reaches the same practical result differently: proceedings before the Commission are in rem, so no arbitration agreement between the informant and the enterprise could displace them.

3. Why Unfair Trade Practices Were Moved

The MRTP Act covered unfair trade practices from 1984, and the Raghavan Committee recommended that they be excluded from the new competition law. The reason is that they concern the fairness of dealings with individual buyers rather than the structure of markets, and they require no market power: a trader with one per cent of a market can mislead its customers as effectively as one with fifty. Including them would have diverted an expert economic regulator into adjudicating individual grievances, which is the work of the consumer fora. On the repeal of the MRTP Act in 2009 the pending unfair trade practice cases were accordingly transferred to the consumer commission machinery.

4. Related Topics and Provisions

Topic or provision

Connection

Competition Law and the Neighbouring Regimes

The five distinctions treated together

The Values behind Competition Law

Consumer welfare in the competition sense

Appeals and Judicial Remedies

Compensation under Section 53N

Sections 4(2)(a)(i), 53N and 62, Competition Act, 2002

Unfair conditions, compensation and the saving of other laws

Consumer Protection Act, 2019

Unfair trade practices and the individual remedy