Specific Relief Act (SRA)
Declaratory Decrees: Sections 34 and 35
Sometimes a person does not want the court to order anyone to do anything; he simply wants his right or his status put beyond dispute. That is the office of the declaratory decree. Under Section 34, a person entitled to a legal character, or to a right as to property, may sue for a declaration against anyone who denies or is interested to deny it, and the court may make the declaration. But there is a proviso: a plaintiff who could ask for further relief must do so, and cannot rest on a bare declaration. Section 35 fixes the effect of the declaration. This note explains both.
Figure: Sections 34 and 35: who may sue, the subject of the declaration, the proviso against a bare declaration, the effect, and the distinctions
1. The Declaration: Section 34
Who may sue, and against whom ▪ The right to sue. Any person entitled to any legal character, or to any right as to any property, may institute a suit against a person who denies, or is interested to deny, his title to such character or right. ▪ The relief. The court may in its discretion make a declaration that he is so entitled; and the plaintiff need not ask for any further relief in the same suit. ▪ Legal character. A person's legal status or capacity: that he is the lawful heir, the adopted son, a citizen, or the holder of an office or status. ▪ Right as to property. A right or interest in property: that he is the owner, that a deed does not bind him, or that he holds a particular title or share. |
2. The Proviso: No Bare Declaration Where Further Relief Is Available
The most important limit ▪ The rule. No court shall make a declaration where the plaintiff, being able to seek further relief than a mere declaration of title, omits to do so. ▪ The classic case. A plaintiff who is out of possession and could sue for possession must claim possession; he cannot sue for a bare declaration of title alone. ▪ Where a bare declaration lies. Where the plaintiff cannot seek any further relief, for example because no consequential relief is open to him, a suit for a bare declaration is maintainable. |
3. The Effect of a Declaration: Section 35
Whom it binds ▪ Parties and privies. A declaration binds only the parties to the suit, and persons claiming through them. ▪ Trustees. Where a party is a trustee, it also binds the persons for whom, if in existence at the date of the declaration, that party would be a trustee. ▪ Not in rem. The declaration binds these persons and no others; it is not a judgment in rem that binds the whole world. |
4. The Nature of the Relief
- Not executable. A declaration is not an executable decree; it grants nothing to be enforced. It states the true legal position and removes a cloud on it.
- Discretionary. The court may decline a declaration even where the plaintiff has the right, if a declaration would serve no useful purpose or the plaintiff has an adequate alternative.
- Often a foundation. A declaration is frequently paired with a further relief, such as possession, injunction or cancellation, which does the actual enforcing.
5. Declaration Distinguished
Pair | The distinction |
|---|---|
Declaration vs cancellation | The executant of a void or voidable deed sues to cancel it; a stranger not bound by it sues for a declaration that it does not bind him |
Declaration vs injunction | A declaration states the right; an injunction commands or restrains conduct. A declaration is often the foundation on which an injunction is granted |
Declaration vs possession | A declaration of title alone will not give possession; a plaintiff out of possession must also claim it, by force of the proviso |
Declaratory vs executable decree | A declaratory decree states the position; an executable decree can be enforced by the process of the court |
6. Frequently Asked Questions
Q. Who may sue for a declaratory decree?
A. Under Section 34, any person entitled to a legal character or to a right as to property may sue for a declaration against a person who denies, or is interested to deny, that title.
Q. Can a plaintiff sue for a bare declaration only?
A. Not where he is able to seek further relief and omits it. A plaintiff out of possession who could ask for possession must claim it; a bare declaration lies only where no further relief is open to him.
Q. Whom does a declaration bind?
A. Under Section 35, only the parties to the suit, those claiming through them, and, where a party is a trustee, the persons for whom he would be a trustee. It is not a judgment in rem.
Q. Is a declaratory decree executable?
A. No. It grants nothing to be enforced; it states the true legal position. It is often paired with a further relief, such as possession or injunction, which does the enforcing.
SEO METADATA URL slug: declaratory-decrees-sections-34-35-specific-relief-act SEO title: Declaratory Decrees: Sections 34 and 35 of the Specific Relief Act Meta description: Sections 34 and 35 of the Specific Relief Act 1963: the declaration of a legal character or right to property, the proviso against a bare declaration where further relief is available, and the effect of the declaration. Keywords: Section 34 Specific Relief Act, declaratory decree, legal character, proviso further relief, Section 35 effect of declaration, declaration vs cancellation |